| Year | Name | Hometown |
| 2019 | Sheila Jackson | Fishers, IN |
| 2019 | Susan Doyle | Pleasant Valley, NY |
| 2019 | Kim Ward | Greenville, TN |
| 2018 | Traci Ayers-Dower | LaFollette, TN |
| 2018 | Lori Jones | Carrollton, TX |
| 2017 | Barbara Ruhter | Hastings, NE |
| 2017 | Judy Bohn | Eagleswood, CO |
| 2016 | Annette Wells | Stevenson, WA |
| 2016 | Jane Aumann | Nokomis, IL |
| 2015 | Delores Nitz* | Fremont, NE |
| 2015 | Barbara Fisher* | Pompano Beach, FL |
| 2015 | Joyce Frey | Archbold, OH |
| 2014 | Sharon Huisman | Galt, CA |
| 2014 | Lynda Dickenson | Castlewood, VA |
| 2013 | Ramona King | Fletcher, NC |
| 2012 | Nancy Manning | Quinlan, TX |
| 2011 | Janet Shearer | Kissimmee, FL |
| 2010 | Joani Mangold | Wickenburg, AZ |
| 2009 | Jean Fleming | Atkinson, NE |
| 2008 | Norma Murphy | Edmond, WA |
| 2008 | Sharon Kurtz | Owensboro, KY |
| 2007 | Judy Marshall | Kearney, NE |
| 2007 | Velda Fannon* | Pennington, VA |
| 2006 | Sherri Theurer | Wellington, KS |
| 2006 | Mary Jo Butts* | Brazil, IN |
| 2005 | Dorothy Albrecht* | Vassar, MI |
| 2005 | Glenda McCarter-Johnson* | Sevierville, TN |
| 2004 | Betty Jo Mendenhall | High Point, NC |
| 2004 | Patricia Lambright* | LaGrange, IN |
| 2003 | Judy Ford | Mt. Vernon, KY |
| 2003 | Joan Rittenhouse* | Vanderbilt, PA |
| 2002 | Pat Zettlemoyer | Breinigsville, PA |
| 2002 | Pat Kiko | North Canton, OH |
| 2001 | Virginia Dilgard | Ashland, OH |
| 2001 | Tomi Ayers | LaFollette, TN |
| 2000 | Lucy Faison* | Zebulon, NC |
| 2000 | Pat Dunning | West Dundee, IL |
| 1999 | Brenda Higgenbotham | Lakeland, FL |
| 1999 | Marjorie Gaule | Springfield, IL |
| 1998 | Doris Todd* | Rome, GA |
| 1998 | Joanne Laumeyer* | Cape Coral, FL |
| 1997 | Irene Erickson* | Buena Vista, AR |
| 1997 | Arlene Buckles* | Keosauqua, IA |
*deceased